Ward 3 Candidate Responses

We received responses from six candidates in this ward. The Calgary Climate Hub is a non-partisan organization, and posting these responses does not indicate an endorsement. Responses are presented in the order they were received and have not been edited.

General Questions

1. What are the top three issues you hope to make progress on during your time on Council?

Brent Trenholm 1. Communication through collaboration. Right now city hall runs on a top down attitude. This desperately needs to change, where all peoples opinions mater, not just loyal supporters. 2. Priorities. When council sets priorities for the coming year they need to originate from constituents not city hall and political wish lists. This means every ward Councillor needs to do their homework within their Ward and present their case. 3. Spending needs to be rained in! What comes out of point 1 & 2 will set the tune for spending, which will be organically built. I also believe there should be a capital fund for each community to address community needs. when the funds are used up that is it until next year. 4. All of the above effects tax rates. So if the constituents are consulted, the priorities and budgets can be set and would fall in line with wants and needs, which is an organic budget that looks at spending and not taxation as a way of solving our budgeting problem.
Nate Pike Trust in elected officials, transit and parks and green spaces.
Ian McAnerin Making sure the needs of Ward 3 are met, Pandemic/Economic recovery, Making the City run better.
Hamayun Akbar 1-Economy-2 Transport-Affordable Housing
Mr Kumar Sharma Job & Economy, Environment & quality of lIfe issues within our City
Jasmine Mian Transit, Pedestrian safety/walkability & improved community engagement

 

2. Women - especially low-wage, racialized and newcomers - have been disproportionately impacted by the pandemic. In your capacity as a public servant, how will you address these impacts and ensure that all women benefit equitably from the economic recovery? 

Brent Trenholm There have been a lot (many) people who have been hit hard by the pandemic and collapsed economy. I have always been of the opinion that support goes to where support needs to go. If anyone ever plays favoritism for anyone race, age, creed, or color, and I find out, I would go to bat and be relentless to ensure egos and positions are pulled from the equation, because people need to be treated equitably.
Nate Pike Emphasizing the importance of that disparity as well as encouraging companies to recognize the strength that women in the work force offer. This includes highlighting that fact in promotional campaigns to attract new corporations to Calgary.
Ian McAnerin

A gender-inclusive recovery is essential to the very concept of a recovery. Making sure that all plans for recovery are also viewed through gender, racial, and accessibility lenses in order to identify shortcomings and biases in decision-making must be an important part of the process.

Part of this includes ensuring the collection and use of accurate data that is capable of highlighting demographics that have been disproportionately affected by the pandemic is crucial, as is using the tools of government (regulations, budgeting, procurement) to help ensure an equitable recovery.

Hamayun Akbar I believe in equal rights for all the people of all the communities so as I public servant I will table a motion we should put extra resources on training required for better jobs.
Mr Kumar Sharma Ensuring Educational Opportunities , affordable day care services and programs which enhance the City Innovation and technology opportunities which our rooted in our City
Jasmine Mian I take an intersectional approach to policymaking. This is the best way to ensure that we create an equitable recovery. For example, certain services have a disproportional effect on women, particularly low-wage workers. This is why I'm a strong advocate for transit and improved walkability in suburban neighbourhoods, which affects the ability of many women to work and access services. When we're building back post-pandemic, we have to use an intersectional lens to ensure we're meeting the needs of all Calgarians, but especially those who have been left out. Another way the city can help women is by making land-use processes easier for childcare providers.

 

3. Calgary has been dipping into emergency funds to pay for operations for the past several years. How would you approach taxation and the delivery of programs and services to Calgarians?

Brent Trenholm This past council has put the cities finances in a bad place. I truly believe that the city has a spending problem. To curb the use of using emergency funds, we would need to do a better job of budgeting. I would move towards canceling $150 million in slush funds and use this money to lower operating costs. The next would be to perform a cost and operational audit from one end of the city to the other. This would bring roughly $20 million in direct operational savings. So In essence the city would do more for the same with less money. I am talking about operational efficiencies. When taxes go up and services go down, this means your operating budget is out of wack with taxation and spending. There is a lot of waste at the city in the manager/supervisory areas. Often you find the wrong person in a position of authority and it costs millions.
Nate Pike The last several years have been exceptionally challenging, and that has forced changes to be made. I would continue the existing efforts initiated to locate savings while not cutting core business services and also support the more balance and diversified approach to managing tax base that has been initiated. 
Ian McAnerin

There are three issues here - first, the budget process that the City of Calgary uses is incremental in nature, which tends to encourage managers to puff up budget requests and create end-of-year spending sprees to defend their department. Calgary should move towards a priority based budget system instead. This has been shown to dramatically lower the cost of government while focusing funds where they are needed.

Second, our reliance on the O&G sector is so high that every hiccup in world oil prices has an effect on the city and it's tax revenue. We need to encourage diversification to minimize the effect.

Third, the provincial government has been making budget cuts by offloading to costs to municipalities like Calgary. Every time Calgary needs to $10 in tax money, it needs to take $16.50 from Calgarians because the province taxes your taxes. In addition, Calgary will lose $2.5 Million from provincial assets in Calgary because they province decided not to pay their bills for the services on these buildings. We need a fairer deal from the province.

Hamayun Akbar In my view oil prices will not reach to 150 dollar per barrel anymore so we should reduce over expenses for non essential spending.
Mr Kumar Sharma Taxation for residential and Commercial Interests is a completed policy and issue for the Citizens of Calgary. It must be fair, equitable and to ensure that the core services of the City are maintained. I support a true zero based budget mechanism as a means for fair taxation
Jasmine Mian

The taxation system was designed to work well when we had a strong non-residential sector. Our changing economy and the pandemic have shown the weaknesses of that system. We need to reform the system and advocate for a better model through intergovernmental collaboration with the province. We don't need more taxation power, but we likely need different tools in our belt given the changing economy and digital age. Municipal revenue is not diversified, which impacts our ability to be resilient in the face of change.

I believe that our city services are important and highly valued. I will advocate strongly to maintain service levels. The city is already down to 2013 staffing levels despite significant population growth. We will not solve what ails us by racing to the bottom. It's going to take hard work and policy innovation in collaboration with the province to provide stability.

 

4. What is your plan for diversifying Calgary’s economy for a just transition away from oil and gas?

Brent Trenholm First it is impossible to remove oil and gas from being used in everyday life. Saying this I believe a lot of these oil and gas companies can play a huge roll in converting to other sources of power, like thermo power and the extraction of lithium from the ground without digging a pit as an example. The other part to this is we need to make it easier to do business at city hall. Right now I feel the city over regulates. if Maggie's boutique wants to set up shop, the first thing we need to do is ask how can we help, then actually help... Instead of here, you need to fill out a book load of forms and fees. Then by the way your tax bill will be XXX next year because of budget short falls. If the city is truly open for business, we hold the line on taxation and fees and we promote the city from within as the best place to do business and mean it. Business will naturally come to town.
Nate Pike First of all by working to ensure that Calgary is net zero in all business groups as well as actively recruiting net zero companies or companies working to get to net zero to come to Calgary.
Ian McAnerin

We don't need to force a transition away from O&G (that will happen naturally), we need to add diversity so O&G becomes a smaller portion of the economy. Putting it another way, it's better to ADD diverse jobs than it is to cause O&G folks to lose their jobs and hoping that they will find a different job in a different area.

As for how to do that, a multi-pronged approach is needed - there isn't a single silver bullet. Tax incentives, creating a welcoming business environment, increasing the standards of living, and even advertising and promotion all play their part. Right now Calgary's reputation comes from Alberta's reputation - which is primarily O&G, leading many non-O&G companies to not even think of us when looking for a location.

Calgary needs it's own brand and system that encourages a diverse economy - a good reputation, a trained workforce, an attractive location for employees, and a business-friendly administration.

Hamayun Akbar The best way to diversify our economy we need to train our people for new skills and attract IT businesses and renewable energy companies to invest in Calgary and offer them tax free for first 2 years.
Mr Kumar Sharma I will continue to support the work and actions of the Calgary Economic and Development Corporation. Once elected to Council and allow me to be informed by City Administration of the various programs close cooperation with both Provincial and Federal Governments is a priority in my mind to help Calgary during these time of economic slowdown
Jasmine Mian

The city plays an important role in attracting new business. In my conversations with folks from Calgary Economic Development, what will attract diverse players isn't simply a low tax environment. It's also strong talent, thriving culture and good services. This is why I strongly advocate for initiatives that will help us retain talent, create culture (arts, sports, recreation, active economy) and provide good services (transit, public safety etc). At the same time, we must stabilize taxes on the non-residential side so that businesses can have more confidence when investing here.

A just transition has to happen system-wide, which is why I believe councillors must build relationships with other orders of government, so that our efforts don't work against each other. The provincial government may not always agree with the city, but without open lines of communication, we can't even have those conversations. We can learn from previous work with coal miners to ensure a just transition.


Climate Change and the Environment

Questions:

1. Will you commit to setting clear interim targets for Calgary and ENMAX to achieve net-zero GHG emissions by 2050 to help limit global warming to 1.5 degrees?

Brent Trenholm Yes
Nate Pike Yes
Ian McAnerin Yes
Hamayun Akbar Yes
Mr Kumar Sharma Yes
Jasmine Mian Yes

 

 

2. Will you work to reduce emissions from buildings to net-zero by (1) ensuring The City's Sustainable Building Policy has clear targets, is transparent, and requires third-party certification, and (2) by providing incentives for privately-owned new buildings and retrofits?

Brent Trenholm I agree with #1, less 3rd party certification. this last part can be take care of inhouse, provided there are clear attainable targets. I am inclined to not agree with #2 by allowing attrition to play a greater role along with providing attainable goals to meet. these types of initiatives should come from the Provincial & Federal government
Nate Pike Yes
Ian McAnerin Yes
Hamayun Akbar Yes
Mr Kumar Sharma Yes
Jasmine Mian Yes

 

3. Will you support policies to ensure zero food waste not only from Calgary's restaurants, groceries, distributors, but also corporate events?

Brent Trenholm Yes
Nate Pike Yes
Ian McAnerin Yes
Hamayun Akbar Yes
Mr Kumar Sharma Yes
Jasmine Mian Yes

 

4. Will you strengthen the City's procurement policies to ensure goods and services are sustainably and ethically sourced? The Chartered Institute of Procurement & Supply states that sustainable procurement "considers the impact of environmental, economic and social factors along with price and quality."

Brent Trenholm Yes
Nate Pike Yes
Ian McAnerin Yes
Hamayun Akbar Yes
Mr Kumar Sharma Yes
Jasmine Mian Yes

 

5. Do you support focusing new development within established areas instead of continuing to approve new developments on the outskirts of Calgary?

Brent Trenholm Yes
Nate Pike Yes
Ian McAnerin Yes
Hamayun Akbar Yes
Mr Kumar Sharma -
Jasmine Mian Yes

 

6. Will you support completion of the Green Line, including crossing the river to 16 Avenue N?

Brent Trenholm Yes
Nate Pike Yes
Ian McAnerin Yes
Hamayun Akbar Yes
Mr Kumar Sharma Yes
Jasmine Mian Yes

 

7. Do you commit to providing equal access to low-cost, low-carbon transportation to all areas of the city, including transit, cycling and pedestrian infrastructure?

Brent Trenholm Yes
Nate Pike Yes
Ian McAnerin Yes
Hamayun Akbar Yes
Mr Kumar Sharma Yes
Jasmine Mian Yes

Equity and Inclusion

1. Which of the following measures will you support to address poverty and social isolation in our city?

  1. Affordable housing
  2. Low-income transit pass
  3. Fair Entry recreation pass
  4. Increased access to childcare
  5. Increased financial support to community associations
  6. Enough for All Poverty Reduction Strategy
  7. Other
  1 2 3 4 5 6 Other
Brent Trenholm           Yes I believe that the first part to this is getting the economy going so people can help themselves by participating in society. Those that would have difficulty there should be funding for support programs
Nate Pike Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes  
Ian McAnerin Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes   I support the Enough for All Poverty Reduction Strategy, but it's target dates were made in 2016 and don't take the effect of the pandemic into account. The target dates need to be revisited.
Hamayun Akbar Yes Yes Yes Yes      
Mr Kumar Sharma             Al;l of the above can be considered for support to address poverty
Jasmine Mian Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes  

 

2. Do you support providing City services primarily through unionized City workers, or do you support contracting out City services to private companies?

  1. Maintain unionized City workers
  2. Contract out
  3. Other
  1 2 Other
Brent Trenholm     There should be a mix of both. The problem here comes down to having unqualified people in positions of authority because of seniority. I am a millwright who worked in a 1200 employee unionized facility. When it came to skilled labor we could do the work cheaper than any other outside business. For unskilled labor there is a wide range of abilities and attitudes. I believe skill level maters. I have also talked with many city workers who are of the same opinion as me that a lot of miss use of time and money comes from managers and supervisors inability to budget, plan and use of manpower. Many jobs and positions should be people based, skill, training and maybe incentives to do more with less. One of the biggest problems is managing through the buddy system. I also think that a few key people need to relax their ego's and truly look at how they can be better at doing their own job and less attention to others.
Nate Pike Yes    
Ian McAnerin     Services should go through the best option. Sometimes that may be union, sometimes that may be private sector. I won't make a decision before any facts are available. I support making the smartest choice based on facts, not an ideological one made a priori.
Hamayun Akbar Yes    
Mr Kumar Sharma     I believe a balancde is neeed along with a clear understandiing of tthe core serviices thatt a city must provide and to ensure the best of service and quality of work is maintained
Jasmine Mian Yes    

 

3. Would you support Fair Trade Calgary's initiative to make Calgary a globally-designated Fair Trade town? (Find out more at: http://www.fairtradecalgary.com/at-a-glance.html)

Brent Trenholm Yes
Nate Pike Yes
Ian McAnerin Yes
Hamayun Akbar Yes
Mr Kumar Sharma Yes
Jasmine Mian Yes

 

4. Do you support Universal Basic Income?

Brent Trenholm No
Nate Pike Yes
Ian McAnerin Yes
Hamayun Akbar Yes
Mr Kumar Sharma No
Jasmine Mian No

Diversity & Reconciliation

1. What is your plan to address the increase in hate crimes and overt displays of racism in our city?

Brent Trenholm To start with, I believe a lot of the problem stems from our political environment. Politicians mobilizing polarization of thoughts and beliefs to use to their advantage. When people use this as a tool to gain an advantage, or to discredit something or someone because it is the latest craze, I believe this is worse than bigoted people in our city, because they usually keep to themselves. A long time ago they called it bullying. I have "0" patients for this or any other type of acts of bullying, or racism. It is also important to accept that racism goes two ways. This comes back to the family units breaking down, because kids know nothing until their parents start talking. There are two ways to combat this. Pay more attention to a family's needs, create healthy family activities and events. Stop saying that green person over there .... Instead say that person over there if you do not know their name. I have managed hundreds of people and for me I never paid attention to the BS as it comes down to people from all walks of life needing to accept their neighbor and visa versa. Respect. the other part that would help is if the economy got going again many of these problems would end. It is also important to note that 5% of the population will always have hatred in their hearts, and that will probably never change. Of late I have talked with thousands of people with different ethnic backgrounds and it is unanimous by a very large margin that people are people and they need to be treated acordingly
Nate Pike Leadership by example and consulting with the effected groups as to what supports they need.
Ian McAnerin

In the short term, actually enforcing our existing hate speech and hate crime laws would be a good start. Hate speech breeds hate crimes, and if there is no consequence for a hate crime, there is no incentive to stop committing them.

In the longer term, hate speech is a form of education/indoctrination. The best way to combat that is more and better education. Supporting and funding groups that address this is probably the most efficient way of addressing this.

On a related note, support for victims of hate crimes needs to be more readily available, and more obvious. That public support is also a from of education, in addition to the actual support itself.

Hamayun Akbar  
Mr Kumar Sharma The policies and work being undertaken presently in Calgary is a start in the riight direction, however we must work together as Society changes and with other levels of Goverrnmewnt
Jasmine Mian I have already been doing outreach to various community leaders in order to build relationships and to listen. I believe that councillors cannot wait until the community comes to council asking for help or make any real change by passing motions that we think might work. We have to do the outreach and listen to the community, then we have to act. So many groups have been left out of decision making, and I think effective councillors will be those who empower the community.

 

2. How will you support policies to ensure more Indigenous voices are included in making municipal decisions?

Brent Trenholm Calgary is a beautiful city with many incredible people that live in it. It is important for a city and every household to respect everyone. The make up of city government is to function as a city for the tax payers of that city. At any point that municipal government moves outside its physical boundaries proper consultation is always required.
Nate Pike Requiring consultation on all decisions council makes is a minimum.
Ian McAnerin Promotion and inclusion of the Aboriginal Affairs Committee in more council decisions and discussion is needed. In addition, the committee needs to be bigger and have more resources in order to handle the additional work needed.
Hamayun Akbar  
Mr Kumar Sharma Again we have to work win a collective manner with all level of Government and to work to establish the 96 resolutions of the TRC.
Jasmine Mian I personally commit to acting on the calls to action in the White Goose Flying report. I will ask for a stoplight report on the City’s website to keep the public apprised of Council’s progress. Stoplight reports use the colour red to highlight reconciliation initiatives that have not been started, yellow for those that are on-going and green is used to indicate completed recommendations. This level of transparency will allow the public to hold elected officials to account in areas where little progress is being made.

 

3. What steps will you support to increase trust and reduce uses of force by police that disproportionately affect Black, Indigenous and People of Colour in Calgary? (Please use "other" for additional ideas.)

  1. Enthocultural training for police
  2. Increase number of Aboriginal Liaison Officers
  3. Alternative response models (PACT and DOAP teams)
  4. Other
  1 2 3 Other
Brent Trenholm     Yes There are bad employees everywhere, unfortunately the police and positions of authority need to use there brain. unfortunately there are more than enough that do not, which gives everyone else a bad name. Training, high standards, consequences for actions taken.
Nate Pike Yes Yes Yes  
Ian McAnerin Yes Yes Yes  
Hamayun Akbar Yes Yes    
Mr Kumar Sharma       All of the above 
Jasmine Mian Yes Yes Yes  

 


Mental Health & Addictions

1. Which of the following do you support to address mental health and addictions?

  1. Implement alternative emergency response models
  2. Implement trauma-informed care
  3. Supervised consumption sites
  4. Other
  1 2 3 Other
Brent Trenholm Yes      
Nate Pike Yes Yes Yes  
Ian McAnerin Yes Yes Yes Support for non-profit groups that focus on specific, specialized areas that are sometimes overlooked in the big picture.
Hamayun Akbar   Yes Yes  
Mr Kumar Sharma       All of the above
Jasmine Mian Yes Yes Yes  

 


General Comments

Do you have any other comments you would like to share with us?

Brent Trenholm I would like to have seen a question about what type of administrative experience and position have you held. how many years, employees and size of budget.
Nate Pike In working only any decisions that affect any marginalized groups, the city should be using the philosophy of “nothing about us without us” to ensure effective consultation
Ian McAnerin

In order for Calgary to recover from both the poor economy leading up to the pandemic as well as the effects of the pandemic, we can't go back to doing the same old things the same old way - things were already bad before all of this.

We need to focus on reaching a better way of doing things and creating a better Calgary.

Hamayun Akbar  
Mr Kumar Sharma I am seeking the position of an elected official of the City of Calgary. My only comment at this time is my passion "to serve" create change, investt in people and work tro provide a quality of life for Ward 3 and the residence of our entire City Thank you
Jasmine Mian  

 


Other Election Information

  • To see a current list of candidates and other election information including ward boundaries and how to vote, click here.
  • To order a Fast & Fair Climate Action lawn sign, click here.
  • To RSVP for the Mayoral Candidate Forum on September 30, click here.
  • Will you vote on October 18? Sign our pledge and let us know!

This survey was sent out to mayoral and ward councillor candidates throughout July and was developed in collaboration with the following organizations: